close

Background - 17.11.2026 - 13:00 

Is There Still Hope in the Age of AI?

Artificial intelligence is often discussed in terms of its risks. But does focusing on dangers make us overlook its possibilities? Professor Payal Arora explains.

Payal Arora, Professor of Inclusive AI Cultures at Utrecht University, is a digital anthropologist, author and speaker. She is the co-founder of FemLab and the author of the award-winning book The Next Billion Users. Described by Forbes as a "next billion champion" and the "right kind of person to reform tech", she delivered a public lecture at the University of St.Gallen on 4 November 2026 at the invitation of the Institute for Media and Communications Management, calling for a more hopeful approach to technology.

The Paralysis of Pessimism

Technology was once widely associated with progress and the promise of a better future. Today, however, debates surrounding artificial intelligence in the Western world increasingly focus on its risks, ranging from documented harms such as algorithmic discrimination and surveillance to existential scenarios, sometimes amplified by the tech industry, in which AI could threaten humanity itself. Influential works such as The Age of Surveillance Capitalism (2019) by Shoshana Zuboff and Algorithms of Oppression (2018) by Safiya Umoja Noble reflect this critical examination of technology. Alongside alarming media narratives, such debates can contribute to a culture of fear and a growing sense that "the game is already over": AI appears as an overwhelming, inevitable force, leaving people with little power to shape how technology is used or adapted to their own needs and circumstances. Arora warns that this sense of helplessness can lead to a form of paralysis, in which meaningful action and change seem increasingly out of reach.

The Bigger Picture: "From Pessimism to Promise"

Yet this predominantly pessimistic outlook tells only part of the story. Drawing on her research and her book From Pessimism to Promise, Arora pointed to a different attitude towards digital technology in countries such as India, Kenya, Brazil and Mexico, where young people often express greater optimism about its potential.

Understanding this optimism requires looking beyond technology itself. In many communities across the Global South, access to education, healthcare, employment and political participation remains constrained by social and economic inequalities. For younger generations who have witnessed improvements in living conditions compared with those of their parents and grandparents, technological change is therefore not necessarily something to fear. It may open up opportunities that were previously out of reach, particularly where existing institutions have failed to meet people's needs. From digital entrepreneurship and creative expression to information, education and social connections, technology can help people participate in areas of life from which they have traditionally been excluded.

“Hope is a moral imperative. Because hope is the architect in the way you think and the way you act.”
Prof. Payal Arora

Arora tells the story of a young woman from rural India who, through social media, can showcase her handmade clothes to a wider audience, reach customers far beyond her village and turn her creativity into a livelihood. What begins with a simple online profile can become much more than a business: a path to financial independence, an opportunity to make her voice heard and the freedom to shape her own future.

“Pessimism is a privilege.”
Prof. Payal Arora

Such experiences, encountered by Arora throughout her research, illustrate why optimism in these contexts is not necessarily naïve, but rational. For many people, hope is not simply a choice, but a necessity for actively shaping their own future. It reflects their experiences, circumstances and aspirations.

The Same Technology, Different Realities

What makes technology harmful or beneficial? For Arora, the answer cannot be separated from the context in which it is used. While social media algorithms can reinforce discrimination and inequality, digital platforms have also helped movements such as #MeToo and Black Lives Matter gain visibility and mobilise people around the world. The same technology, in other words, can have very different effects depending on the context. For Arora, acknowledging these opportunities does not mean overlooking the risks associated with technology. Rather, she encourages a broader perspective that takes into account the different ways technologies affect people's lives. "Mindsets do matter", she emphasised during her lecture. The way we perceive technology shapes not only how we respond to it, but also the questions we ask and the solutions we seek. Research that focuses primarily on how technologies harm marginalised communities, for example, may overlook how those same communities use them to overcome challenges and create opportunities. For Arora, the answer lies in what she calls "contextual intelligence": understanding how and why people use technologies in different circumstances. Her argument is not to abandon critical research, but to broaden its perspective beyond identifying risks to also explore what is working and what could be improved.

“So it's a messy situation, and we need to delve into the messiness. Empathetic and with contextual intelligence.”
Prof. Payal Arora

According to Arora, researchers, policymakers and technology developers should learn from those people who use technologies to overcome challenges and involve them in shaping future innovations. It also means looking beyond familiar Western models. She calls for greater international exchange and a willingness to learn from solutions emerging in often-overlooked communities. For Arora, reclaiming hope is therefore not simply about seeing technology more positively, but about recognising possibilities for change and actively working to realise them.

Arora's perspective offers one of many possible ways of understanding the opportunities and challenges of emerging technologies such as AI. Yet the debate extends far beyond a single perspective. Those interested in exploring different viewpoints can listen to the HSG podcast Machines That Fail Us, discover further articles and insights in the HSG Newsroom's AI topic section, or explore ongoing HSG research, from the technological foundations and applications of AI at the Chair of Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning to its implications for human behaviour and society at the AI Impact Lab.

Image: Pixabay

north